The delayed onset and long-term course of the Lyme rash – can erythema migrans recur?

  • 2026 July 22.
  • 1271 megtekintés

Lyme borreliosis is the most common tick-borne bacterial infectious disease in Europe, caused by bacteria belonging to the Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato group. In Hungary, several thousand new cases are diagnosed each year, but the actual number of cases is likely to be much higher, as not all patients seek medical attention, and the early symptoms of the condition are not always recognised in time. The best-known early symptom of the disease is the Lyme rash, medically known as erythema migrans, which in many cases is the only warning sign that a Borrelia infection has developed in the body; however, it is important to note that it only appears in just one-third of cases.

However, the appearance of the Lyme rash raises numerous questions for patients. Does it only ever appear once? Could it reappear in the same place or elsewhere? What does it mean if a similar skin lesion develops again months or even years after treatment? Is it possible that a Lyme rash might develop again following another tick bite, or does this indicate a recurrence of the previous infection? The answers to these questions are not always straightforward, as the immunology and clinical course of Lyme disease differ from those of many other bacterial infections.

When does the Lyme rash appear?

Following a bite from an infected tick, the bacteria begin to multiply in the skin. The Lyme rash usually appears 3–30 days after the tick bite, most commonly within one or two weeks. Observations suggest that one likely cause of the rash is the spread of the bacteria within the skin tissue (Borrelia is more successfully cultured or detected from the red, expanding outer ring), but there are numerous indications that the rash may sometimes be an allergic-type reaction to proteins found in the tick’s saliva. If the rash develops within a few hours or days of the bite, it is likely that this is not the body’s first encounter with an infected tick. It is important to note that many patients do not notice the tick at all, particularly if they were bitten whilst the tick was still in its larval or nymphal stage. For this reason, it is common for the patient to notice only that a red patch is beginning to grow on their skin, whilst having no recollection of a tick bite.

However, the developing redness does not in itself indicate Lyme disease. A slightly red, possibly itchy reaction measuring a few millimetres at the site of the tick bite may be a completely normal immune response, which resolves on its own within a few days. In contrast, erythema migrans grows gradually, usually exceeding 5 centimetres in diameter, and continues to spread over several days.

Patients also often report that the tick bite is itchy or that the bite site is painful. These symptoms do not in themselves indicate Lyme borreliosis. A true Lyme rash is usually not painful and does not itch significantly, although mild itching or discomfort may occur. It is much more characteristic of the condition to see a slow, centrifugal spread, during which the redness gradually expands outwards, whilst the centre often becomes paler, and a red patch remains in the immediate vicinity of the bite – this is how the characteristic ‘cockade’ pattern develops.

It is not uncommon for a minor inflammatory reaction to appear initially at the site of the bite, followed, after a few days or weeks, by the development of erythema migrans independently of this. It is therefore important for patients to realise that a simple local skin reaction and the Lyme rash are not the same thing.

Are all Lyme rashes the same?

The ‘bow-tie shaped’ Lyme rash commonly depicted in the public imagination is actually only observed in some cases. Alongside the classic erythema migrans – characterised by a ring-like pattern with a paler central band – numerous other forms are known.

A Lyme rash may be completely uniform red, oval, with irregular edges, or even have a slightly purplish tinge. There may be no paler centre at all, meaning it can easily be mistaken for other skin conditions or insect bites. For this reason, simply comparing photographs can be misleading, as skin symptoms can vary significantly from one patient to another.

For diagnostic purposes, the behaviour of the rash is far more important than its exact appearance. The gradual spread of erythema migrans, the possibility of exposure to an infected tick, and the clinical picture as a whole are far more significant than the shape of the skin lesion on its own.

Can more than one Lyme rash appear?

Yes. In the early stages of Lyme disease, it is possible for more than one skin lesion to appear. If the Borrelia bacteria spread to other parts of the body via the bloodstream, multiple Lyme spots (multiple erythema migrans) may develop.

In such cases, the patient usually has a primary, larger lesion at the site of the tick bite, followed a few days or weeks later by smaller, similar-looking red patches on the trunk or limbs. These are not the result of further tick bites, but rather secondary skin symptoms developing as part of the same infection.

Multiple erythema migrans is less common in Europe than in North America, which can be partly explained by the different species of Borrelia. In Europe, the disease is most commonly caused by Borrelia garinii and Borrelia afzelii, whilst in North America it is caused by Borrelia burgdorferi sensu stricto, and their clinical behaviour differs to some extent.

Can the Lyme rash return after treatment?

This is one of the most common questions asked by patients. Many people believe that if a similar skin lesion reappears months or years after successful antibiotic treatment, it must be a ‘recurrence’ of the previous infection.

However, based on current scientific knowledge, most such cases are not relapses but re-infections.

This has been confirmed by several large-scale studies. In a classic study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, Borrelia strains detected during the initial and recurrent episodes of erythema migrans were compared using molecular genetic methods. The researchers found that the genetic makeup of the bacteria detected on the second occasion differed in every case from the strain identified during the initial infection. This demonstrated that patients were not continuing to battle the same infection, but had become reinfected as a result of a new tick bite.

This observation is particularly important because it highlights that the natural immunity developed following Lyme borreliosis is not complete. In other words, anyone who has previously had Lyme disease can become ill again later if bitten by another infected tick. This is because there is considerable genetic and serotypic diversity within Borrelia burgdorferi, meaning that the bacterial antigen profile of the previous infection is highly unlikely to be similar to that of the new infection.  Re-infection is particularly likely to occur in people who frequently spend time in wooded or scrubby areas, or who are regularly exposed to ticks due to their work or hobbies.

The after-effects of the Lyme rash – how does it disappear, and how long might it remain visible?

One of the most common questions patients ask after starting a course of antibiotics is how long the Lyme rash will remain visible, and when they can be considered cured. Many people worry that if the redness does not fade within a few days, the treatment has been ineffective or the bacteria are still present in the body. The reality, however, is far more complex.

Erythema migrans does not disappear overnight. Even with appropriate antibiotic treatment, it is entirely natural for the skin lesion to fade gradually over a period of weeks. The larger the diameter of the rash at the start of treatment, the longer it will take for it to disappear completely. In some cases, the skin may remain slightly discoloured even months later; however, this is not a sign of an active infection but rather indicates post-inflammatory regeneration.

Clinical studies show that the vast majority of successfully treated erythema migrans recedes significantly within a few weeks, but mild residual discolouration may be noticeable for up to 2–3 months. This is particularly noticeable in people with fair skin and often causes unnecessary concern.

It is important to emphasise that the residual mark visible on the skin does not in itself mean that the Borrelia bacterium is still present. The resolution of the inflammatory process and the complete regeneration of the skin may take considerably longer than the elimination of the infection itself.

What happens if the patch does not fade?

In rare cases, erythema migrans may not fade at the expected rate, or the patient may feel that it is starting to grow again. In such cases, the clinical situation must always be reassessed.

Firstly, it must be clarified whether this is indeed the same skin lesion. It is not uncommon for the patient to mistake a new insect bite, an allergic reaction, a fungal infection or another skin condition for the return of the previous Lyme rash. A significant proportion of dermatological conditions can resemble erythema migrans; therefore, the diagnosis must always be based on the full clinical picture.

If active growth resumes at the site of the previous rash, or if new symptoms – such as fever, neurological symptoms, joint inflammation or cardiac arrhythmia – develop, a repeat medical examination is necessary.

Can a new Lyme rash develop elsewhere on the body?

The answer is yes, but there are several possible reasons for this.

One possibility is that, during the disseminated stage of the disease, several skin lesions develop simultaneously. These so-called multiple erythema migrans lesions are part of the same infection. In such cases, it is not a matter of a new tick bite, but rather that the Borrelia bacteria have spread to other areas of the skin via the bloodstream.

It is a completely different situation when, months or years after successful treatment, a new, classic Lyme rash appears, and in a completely different part of the body at that.

According to the current literature, the vast majority of these cases are the result of a new infection, rather than a recurrence of a previous infection.

Studies investigating reinfection have yielded particularly interesting findings. In patients who became ill again, the new erythema migrans was often smaller in size, multiple skin lesions developed less frequently, and symptoms appeared sooner. One possible reason for this is that, whilst the partial immune response developed during the previous infection does not completely prevent reinfection, it may influence its course.

What does it mean if the site of a tick bite turns red again?

Many patients continue to check the site of a previous tick bite regularly, even months later, and are alarmed if mild redness reappears there.

There are numerous possible causes for minor redness at the site of the bite. These may include mechanical irritation, eczema, other insect bites, folliculitis or simple skin irritation. None of these should automatically be regarded as a recurrence of Lyme disease.

One of the most important characteristics of true erythema migrans remains that it continues to grow. A red spot measuring a few millimetres or a slight swelling from a tick bite, which remains unchanged or disappears within a few days, does not in itself indicate an active Borrelia infection.

Is a repeat serological test necessary?

The diagnosis of Lyme disease remains a clinical diagnosis. Both international and national guidelines emphasise that, in the case of characteristic erythema migrans, serological testing is not required either to establish the diagnosis or to initiate treatment. This is true; however, if serological testing is not carried out immediately after the bite, we miss the only opportunity to clarify whether the case involves re-infection or a primary infection.

More importantly, following successful antibiotic treatment, antibodies may remain detectable for months, or even years. For this reason, a positive Lyme serology test is not suitable for determining whether the patient has recovered, or whether any new skin lesions are related to the previous infection. Where possible, we should use direct diagnostic methods, which provide the most accurate results regarding the current infection.

If characteristic erythema migrans reappears months or years later, it must be assessed as a new clinical event. In such cases, the decision should be based not on previous laboratory results, but on the patient’s current symptoms, the likelihood of tick exposure and the nature of the skin lesion.

Summary

The Lyme rash is the most important early warning sign of Lyme borreliosis; however, its appearance and subsequent course are far more variable than most patients assume. Following treatment, the skin lesion usually fades gradually, and any residual discolouration does not in itself indicate a persistent infection. If, months or years later, a characteristic, expanding Lyme rash reappears, current scientific evidence suggests that the most likely cause is not a recurrence of the previous infection, but rather a reinfection resulting from a new tick bite.

Therefore, even after successful treatment for Lyme disease, it remains important to protect against ticks, as a previous infection does not provide complete immunity against a new infection. Early detection and antibiotic treatment started in good time remain the most important means of preventing complications.

Sources:

  1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK578156/
  2. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23150958/
  3. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17879922/
  4. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40133040/
  5. lymenet.hu

(C) Lyme Borreliosis Foundation